Learning guide · experiment · Suggested 15–25 minutes
Calibrated Judgment
About this resource · How to use it · Learning engineering connections
What is this resource?
A guided activity for Calibrated Judgment. Distinguish evidence in a finished argument from evidence in the process behind it. This project opens on a separate site. Use fictional or public material when exploring assessment.
How should I use it?
- Read Before you begin, then use Open the project to try the listed steps alongside this guide.
- Record an observation, explanation, transfer question and next test in the reflection panel. Saving is optional; Print one-page guide produces a paper copy.
How does this connect to LENS and learning engineering?
This activity connects a capability question to observable work and a possible next decision. What would a polished essay conceal about the learner’s independent reasoning? Assessment prototype; inclusion in this collection does not demonstrate assessment validity. Use the reflection to distinguish what you observed from what still needs evidence.
Distinguish evidence in a finished argument from evidence in the process behind it.
Before you begin
This project opens on a separate site. Use fictional or public material when exploring assessment.
Try this
- Inspect how the project treats the essay and the AI dialogue as different evidence sources.
- Examine the quotations supporting a score and identify what they do and do not show.
- Identify a judgment that should remain with an instructor.
Keep this guide open while you explore.
Reflect
What changed in your explanation after trying this?
Observation → Explanation → Transfer → Next test
Pause & make sense
What are you taking away?
What changed in your explanation after trying this?
Help me make sense of this
- Separate what happened from why. Your observation is the result; your explanation is a claim that may need testing.
- Check another explanation. What else could account for the result? What comparison would distinguish them?
- Try without the support. Could you explain or perform the task in a new situation? Identify what evidence you would need.
- Choose one next move. Return to the concept, compare another example, or test one changed assumption.
Choose your next move
Return to the process, or examine how evidence could change a design.
Choose another question on the map