Learning guide · experiment · Suggested 15–25 minutes

Calibrated Judgment

About this resource · How to use it · Learning engineering connections

What is this resource?

A guided activity for Calibrated Judgment. Distinguish evidence in a finished argument from evidence in the process behind it. This project opens on a separate site. Use fictional or public material when exploring assessment.

How should I use it?

  1. Read Before you begin, then use Open the project to try the listed steps alongside this guide.
  2. Record an observation, explanation, transfer question and next test in the reflection panel. Saving is optional; Print one-page guide produces a paper copy.

How does this connect to LENS and learning engineering?

This activity connects a capability question to observable work and a possible next decision. What would a polished essay conceal about the learner’s independent reasoning? Assessment prototype; inclusion in this collection does not demonstrate assessment validity. Use the reflection to distinguish what you observed from what still needs evidence.

Distinguish evidence in a finished argument from evidence in the process behind it.

Before you begin

This project opens on a separate site. Use fictional or public material when exploring assessment.

Try this

  1. Inspect how the project treats the essay and the AI dialogue as different evidence sources.
  2. Examine the quotations supporting a score and identify what they do and do not show.
  3. Identify a judgment that should remain with an instructor.
Open the project (opens in a new tab)

Keep this guide open while you explore.

Pause & make sense

What are you taking away?

What changed in your explanation after trying this?

Optional. Notes are not sent to a server or scored. Browser storage is specific to this device and can be cleared; download a copy to keep it. Avoid sensitive information on shared devices.

Open my notebook

Notes stay on this page unless you choose to save or download them.

Help me make sense of this
  1. Separate what happened from why. Your observation is the result; your explanation is a claim that may need testing.
  2. Check another explanation. What else could account for the result? What comparison would distinguish them?
  3. Try without the support. Could you explain or perform the task in a new situation? Identify what evidence you would need.
  4. Choose one next move. Return to the concept, compare another example, or test one changed assumption.

Choose your next move

Return to the process, or examine how evidence could change a design.

ExpertTrace →Evidence-to-Impact Mapper →
Choose another question on the map